Chasing K1 Weekly · No. 4
Chasing K1 Weekly, No. 4: Three Rounds, One Bad Afternoon, and an 8 Percent Chance
The fourth weekly letter on the promotion race covers three rounds: Suwon FC's home defeat to Chungnam Asan in Round 30, Seoul E-Land's 4-2 loss at Yongin in Round 31 and the 3-2 win over Jeonnam in Round 32. Seoul's chance of an automatic place went from 23 percent to 34 to 8, and third place is now the race that is really open.
The fourth edition of the weekly letter, and the first on the new model. There was no letter after Round 30, so this one covers three rounds, from Seoul’s bye to the win over Jeonnam on Saturday. The Chasing K1 page stays as the running summary; this is the diary.
The number this week
8 percent. That is the model’s chance, after 250,000 simulated finishes from the table after Saturday’s Round 32 matches, that Seoul E-Land finish first or second and go up without a playoff. Suwon FC are at 86 percent, Daegu at 6. Suwon Samsung win the league in 96 percent of runs and finish in the top two in more than 99.
Weekly No. 3 promised that the next edition would use the new model and recompute its number on it. The first six rows below came from the old model; the rest come from the new one, rerun on the table as it stood each week.
| Edition | Table through | Model | Seoul top two | Suwon FC top two | Daegu top two | Seoul projected | Suwon FC projected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, after the Suwon preview | Round 25 | old | 37% | 70% | 7% | 60.1 | 62.1 |
| Sep 18, after the Suwon defeat | Round 26 | old | 21% | 57% | 24% | 58.3 | 60.7 |
| Sep 21, Weekly No. 1 | Round 27 | old | 22% | 77% | 6% | 59.8 | 62.8 |
| Oct 9, the Gimpo digest | Round 28, Friday | old | 22% | 82% | 3% | 60.9 | 64.0 |
| Oct 11, Weekly No. 2 | Round 28 | old | 18% | 82% | 2% | 61.0 | 64.1 |
| Oct 18, Weekly No. 3 | Round 29 | old | 26% | 74% | 2% | 62.6 | 64.7 |
| Oct 18, recomputed | Round 29 | new | 23% | 74% | 5% | 61.1 | 63.6 |
| Oct 26, Chasing K1 refresh | Round 30 | new | 34% | 51% | 16% | 61.0 | 61.6 |
| Nov 1, recomputed | Round 31 | new | 13% | 77% | 11% | 59.0 | 62.5 |
| Nov 7, this edition | Round 32, Saturday | new | 8% | 86% | 6% | 60.3 | 63.9 |
The highest the number has been on the new model was 34 percent, after Seoul’s bye week. Two rounds later it is 8.
Round 30, October 24 and 25: the week Seoul did not play
Seoul E-Land had the bye, their second of the season.
Suwon FC 0-1 Chungnam Asan. A Suwon FC own goal on 26 minutes ended a 15-match unbeaten run, and the game in hand they had held all autumn was gone. Before the round the model had made Suwon FC 52 percent to win it.
Seongnam 0-2 Suwon Samsung. A seventh straight win for the leaders.
Jeonnam 2-4 Daegu. Daegu moved to two points behind second.
Net effect: Seoul from 23 percent to 34, Suwon FC from 74 to 51, Daegu from 5 to 16. For one week second place was close to a coin flip, and Seoul’s next match was at the side in 13th.
Round 31, October 31 and November 1: Yongin
Yongin 4-2 Seoul E-Land. The afternoon this letter will remember. Seoul had 68 percent of the ball, 19 shots and ten corners, and lost their captain Park Chang-hwan to an ankle injury after 21 minutes. They conceded four: the first on the break, the second from Caio’s back pass, a penalty and a counter-attack in the tenth minute of stoppage time. Gabriel scored twice for Yongin, who had never won two league matches in a row before. Kim Do-gyun: “We lost with nothing to complain about.” After Round 30 the model had made Seoul 45 percent to win; a win would have taken their chance to about half. The Round 31 digest has the match.
Daegu 2-2 Suwon Samsung. In front of 12,230, the leaders’ winning run ended at seven.
Suwon FC 1-0 Ansan. On the Sunday, the day after Seoul’s defeat, and back to three points clear.
Net effect: Seoul from 34 percent to 13, Suwon FC from 51 to 77, Daegu from 16 to 11.
Round 32, November 7: Jeonnam
Seoul E-Land 3-2 Jeonnam. A goal down on 15 minutes, level from the penalty spot on 42, ahead from the spot again on 52 after a VAR review, and 3-1 on 72 through Park Jae-yong before Jeonnam pulled one back. Euller’s two penalties take him to 13 goals, his best season. Kim Do-gyun said he was not satisfied and that luck had helped. The Round 32 digest has the match.
Suwon FC 3-0 Gyeongnam. Earlier the same afternoon.
Seongnam 0-1 Daegu. Also on Saturday.
Still to come on Sunday: Suwon Samsung v Yongin, where a draw clinches promotion for the leaders, plus Cheonan v Busan and Paju v Chungnam Asan.
Net effect: Seoul from 13 percent to 8, Suwon FC from 77 to 86, Daegu from 11 to 6. All three won, so the gaps did not move, but the same three-point gap with two matches left is worth more to Suwon FC than it was with three.
Where everyone stands after Saturday’s Round 32 matches
| # | Club | P | Pts | GF | Left | Home | Away | Top two |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Suwon Samsung | 29 | 63 | 50 | 3 | 2 | 1 | >99% |
| 2 | Suwon FC | 30 | 60 | 57 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 86% |
| 3 | Seoul E-Land | 30 | 57 | 57 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 8% |
| 4 | Daegu | 30 | 56 | 58 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 6% |
| 5 | Busan | 29 | 48 | 47 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 0% |
| 6 | Hwaseong | 31 | 48 | 45 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0% |
What each Suwon FC result does to Seoul
| Round | Date | Suwon FC fixture | Suwon FC win | Seoul top two if Suwon FC win | If they don’t |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | Sat Nov 21, 16:30 | Gimpo (A) | 47% | 2% | 14% |
| 34 | Sun Nov 29, 14:00 | Chungbuk Cheongju (H) | 64% | 3% | 18% |
If Suwon FC win at Gimpo the day before Seoul play Chungnam Asan, Seoul’s chance is close to gone.
What Seoul’s next match does to the number
Chungnam Asan at Mokdong on Sunday November 22, 16:30. The model makes it 42 percent Seoul, 31 draw, 27 Chungnam Asan.
| Result against Chungnam Asan | Seoul top two |
|---|---|
| Seoul win | 18% |
| Draw | 3% |
| Seoul lose | under 1% |
The race for third
With second slipping away, the place that is genuinely open is third. Seoul are on 57 and Daegu on 56, and Daegu have scored one more goal, 58 to 57, so if they finish level on points and the goal totals stay as they are, Daegu go above. The model has Seoul third in 43 percent of runs and fourth in 49; Daegu are third in 46 and fourth in 48.
It matters because of how the playoffs work. Third plays sixth in the semi-finals on December 2 and fourth plays fifth, both at the higher seed’s ground, with the higher seed going through on a draw. Third also hosts the final on December 5 if they get there, again with a draw enough for the home side. And even the loser of the final gets one more chance, a playoff against K League 1’s bottom club, so this year up to four K League 2 clubs can go up. The Long Way Up has the details.
Daegu’s last two are Gimhae at home, which the model makes 73 percent Daegu, and Cheonan away. Seoul’s are Chungnam Asan at home and Gyeongnam away.
What Seoul need from here
Two matches; the possible totals run from 57 to 63, and the model projects 60.3. Second place needs two wins, which happen in 19 percent of runs, and then Suwon FC to drop at least three of their six points: if they win one and lose one, it goes to goals scored, where the two clubs are level on 57 and Seoul come out above about seven times in ten. Third place needs Seoul to stay ahead of Daegu, which in practice means matching their results. Kim Do-gyun said on Saturday that the win had at least kept Seoul in a position to keep chasing. The chase starts against the side that beat them 3-0 in May.
Next edition after Round 33.